External Email - Use Caution
Dear all,
I'm new to
freesurfer and I'm trying to preprocess a 7T mp2rage dataset (0.6mm³
isotropic, TR=6000ms, TE=2.05ms) with freesurfer 7.2.0.
The images have been corrected for B1, for intensity
inhomogeneity with ANTs N4 bias field removal and they were
skull striped with FSL based
on intensity. This was done by a colleague who analyzed this
dataset in 2017 and I'm hoping to run our updated toolboxes on
the preprocessed
data. However, he ran into several problems while first
analyzing the data: freesurfer did not like the noisy
background of the mp2rage, which is why
he skullstripped the data before preprocessing it with
freesurfer. He then ran recon-all once with the default
pipeline and once with skull strip deactivated.
According to him, the default pipeline yielded better results.
I'm using his skull-stripped data now for the preprocessing
and was wondering whether not
deactivating the skull strip will lead to inaccurate measures
for cortical thickness and gray matter volume. Since this is
crucial for our toolboxes, we really
want to be sure that we're going for the best solution. A
second problem is the high resolution of the data - it's not
recommended to run the default recon-all
on anything lower than 1mm³
(MailScanner has detected a possible fraud attempt from "secure-web.cisco.com" claiming to be https://surfer.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/fswiki/SubmillimeterRecon),
but most of the information I could find is from 2016 or 2017.
At the time, he used the -hires flag but got very bad results,
which made him use the default pipeline even if the mp2rage
data got downsampled. I was
wondering if anybody has feedback on how they analyzed a
similar dataset (high resolution, problems with skullstripping
etc.), general opinions on the best
way to analyze this dataset and/or if there have been any
developments (e.g., new flags for recon-all flags?) that I'm
not aware of. We got feedback from
one colleague that they did analyze their dataset successfully
with the -hires flag and did not encounter any problems at the
time. Any advice would be much
appreciated!
Best and thanks in advance,
Sabrina
-- Dr. Sabrina Turker (she/her) Postdoctoral researcher Brain and Language Lab Department of Behavioral & Cognitive Biology University of Vienna