Hi freesurfer experts,
I have a question about how running first-level analyses in either native space or fsaverage space changes activation. My original analysis was a per-session analysis run on native space. The command used to make the analysis was
ANALYSIS 1:
mkanalysis-sess -analysis SIRP_LoadRegression_Stable5_050514 -TR 2 -paradigm slopepar -event-related -runlistfile runlistfile -tpef tpef_1.5mm.txt -native -fwhm 5 -timewindow 20 -TER 2 -nconditions 9 -gammafit 2.25 1.25 -refeventdur 2
However, my lab was interested in running our analyses -per-run, so I created a new per-run analysis on the fsaverage brain using the command:
ANALYSIS 2:
mkanalysis-sess -analysis SIRP_LoadRegression_Stable5_072915_lh -TR 2 -paradigm slopepar -event-related -runlistfile runlistfile -tpef tpef_1.5mm.txt -surface fsaverage lh -fwhm 5 -per-run -timewindow 20 -TER 2 -nconditions 9 -gammafit 2.25 1.25 -refevendur 2 -fsd bold
The group maps for the two looked comparable. However, I covaried those maps with performance on our task. The maps looked significantly different, and while 9 cluster survived MC correction from analysis 1 (3 LH, 6 RH), only 3 survived MC correction from analysis 2 (0 LH, 2 RH).
I thought that the difference could have been due to per-run vs. per-session MC, but I created a test analysis (per-session, fsaverage space), and this analysis looked more like the 2nd analysis than the 1st, leading me to believe that the difference in activation was due to running the first-level analysis on fsaverage space rather than native space.
The command I used for the test analysis was: mkanalysis-sess -analysis TEST_fsaverage_persession_lh -TR 2 -paradigm slopepar -surface fsaverage lh -event-related -fsd bold -runlistfile runlistfile -tpef tpef_1.5mm.txt -timewindow 20 -TER 2 -nconditions 9 -gammafit 2.25 1.25 -refeventdur 2 -fwhm 5 -per-session
Do you know why running first-level analyses on fsaverage space rather than native space would decrease activation effects, leading to fewer significant clusters after MC correction?
I've attached a pdf file with the maps in question.
Thanks,
Anais