External Email - Use Caution
Dear experts,
I noticed suspicious values of segmentation volume in aseg.stats in subjects processed with version 6, with recon-all modified for HCP data.
There is striking difference between BrainSegVolNotVent and BrainSegVolNotVentSurf. The values of BrainSegVolNotVent seem implasibly high. See example values of one of my subjects:
# Title Segmentation Statistics
#
# generating_program mri_segstats
# cvs_version $Id: mri_segstats.c,v 1.121 2016/05/31 17:27:11 greve Exp $
# cmdline mri_segstats --seg mri/aseg.mgz --sum stats/aseg.stats --pv mri/norm.mgz --empty --brainmask mri/brainmask.mgz --brain-vol-from-seg --excludeid 0 --excl-ctxgmwm --supratent --subcortgray --in mri/norm.mgz --in-intensity-name norm --in-intensity-units MR --etiv --surf-wm-vol --surf-ctx-vol --totalgray --euler --ctab /my_freesurfer_home/ASegStatsLUT.txt --subject mysubj
# sysname Linux
# hostname myhost
# machine x86_64
# user    skoch
# anatomy_type volume
#
# SUBJECTS_DIR /my_subjects
# subjectname mysubj
# Measure BrainSeg, BrainSegVol, Brain Segmentation Volume, 3474569.000000, mm^3
# Measure BrainSegNotVent, BrainSegVolNotVent, Brain Segmentation Volume Without Ventricles, 3432059.000000, mm^3
# Measure BrainSegNotVentSurf, BrainSegVolNotVentSurf, Brain Segmentation Volume Without Ventricles from Surf, 1444546.289023, mm^3
# Measure VentricleChoroidVol, VentricleChoroidVol, Volume of ventricles and choroid plexus, 33665.000000, mm^3
# Measure lhCortex, lhCortexVol, Left hemisphere cortical gray matter volume, 268625.129703, mm^3
# Measure rhCortex, rhCortexVol, Right hemisphere cortical gray matter volume, 268347.204256, mm^3
# Measure Cortex, CortexVol, Total cortical gray matter volume, 536972.333959, mm^3
# Measure lhCerebralWhiteMatter, lhCerebralWhiteMatterVol, Left hemisphere cerebral white matter volume, 158213.556983, mm^3
# Measure rhCerebralWhiteMatter, rhCerebralWhiteMatterVol, Right hemisphere cerebral white matter volume, 156867.398082, mm^3
# Measure CerebralWhiteMatter, CerebralWhiteMatterVol, Total cerebral white matter volume, 315080.955064, mm^3
# Measure SubCortGray, SubCortGrayVol, Subcortical gray matter volume, 159729.000000, mm^3
# Measure TotalGray, TotalGrayVol, Total gray matter volume, 1034461.333959, mm^3
# Measure SupraTentorial, SupraTentorialVol, Supratentorial volume, 1036297.289023, mm^3
# Measure SupraTentorialNotVent, SupraTentorialVolNotVent, Supratentorial volume, 1002632.289023, mm^3
# Measure SupraTentorialNotVentVox, SupraTentorialVolNotVentVox, Supratentorial volume voxel count, 2998814.000000, mm^3
# Measure Mask, MaskVol, Mask Volume, 5060060.000000, mm^3
# Measure BrainSegVol-to-eTIV, BrainSegVol-to-eTIV, Ratio of BrainSegVol to eTIV, 2.172140, unitless
# Measure MaskVol-to-eTIV, MaskVol-to-eTIV, Ratio of MaskVol to eTIV, 3.163315, unitless
# Measure lhSurfaceHoles, lhSurfaceHoles, Number of defect holes in lh surfaces prior to fixing, 62, unitless
# Measure rhSurfaceHoles, rhSurfaceHoles, Number of defect holes in rh surfaces prior to fixing, 48, unitless
# Measure SurfaceHoles, SurfaceHoles, Total number of defect holes in surfaces prior to fixing, 110, unitless
# Measure EstimatedTotalIntraCranialVol, eTIV, Estimated Total Intracranial Volume, 1599606.583237, mm^3
# SegVolFile mri/aseg.mgz
# SegVolFileTimeStamp 2018/05/09 15:43:12
# ColorTable /my_freesurfer_home/ASegStatsLUT.txt
# ColorTableTimeStamp 2017/01/18 23:00:02
# InVolFile mri/norm.mgz
# InVolFileTimeStamp 2018/05/07 13:29:02
# InVolFrame 0
# PVVolFile mri/norm.mgz
# PVVolFileTimeStamp 2018/05/07 13:29:02
# Excluding Cortical Gray and White Matter
# ExcludeSegId 0 2 3 41 42
# VoxelVolume_mm3 0.343
# TableCol 1 ColHeader Index
# TableCol 1 FieldName Index
# TableCol 1 Units    NA
# TableCol 2 ColHeader SegId
# TableCol 2 FieldName Segmentation Id
# TableCol 2 Units    NA
# TableCol 3 ColHeader NVoxels
# TableCol 3 FieldName Number of Voxels
# TableCol 3 Units    unitless
# TableCol 4 ColHeader Volume_mm3
# TableCol 4 FieldName Volume
# TableCol 4 Units    mm^3
# TableCol 5 ColHeader StructName
# TableCol 5 FieldName Structure Name
# TableCol 5 Units    NA
# TableCol 6 ColHeader normMean
# TableCol 6 FieldName Intensity normMean
# TableCol 6 Units    MR
# TableCol 7 ColHeader normStdDev
# TableCol 7 FieldName Itensity normStdDev
# TableCol 7 Units    MR
# TableCol 8 ColHeader normMin
# TableCol 8 FieldName Intensity normMin
# TableCol 8 Units    MR
# TableCol 9 ColHeader normMax
# TableCol 9 FieldName Intensity normMax
# TableCol 9 Units    MR
# TableCol 10 ColHeader normRange
# TableCol 10 FieldName Intensity normRange
# TableCol 10 Units    MR
# NRows 45
# NTableCols 10
# ColHeaders Index SegId NVoxels Volume_mm3 StructName normMean normStdDev normMin normMax normRangeÂ
 1  4    14344    5109.0 Left-Lateral-Ventricle           33.1230   13.9291    5.0000   93.0000   88.0000
 2  5     1383     503.7 Left-Inf-Lat-Vent                40.0911   14.4387   10.0000   86.0000   76.0000
 3  7    38137   13247.3 Left-Cerebellum-White-Matter     80.9953    6.2349   21.0000   97.0000   76.0000
 4  8   165378   56702.4 Left-Cerebellum-Cortex           63.3988    8.4866   13.0000   93.0000   80.0000
 5 10    21580    7298.1 Left-Thalamus-Proper             86.6751   10.0317   34.0000  112.0000   78.0000
 6 11    11020    3773.5 Left-Caudate                     75.3689    7.7926   39.0000  107.0000   68.0000
 7 12    12372    4236.2 Left-Putamen                     81.2602    6.8960   41.0000  108.0000   67.0000
 8 13     5644    1867.1 Left-Pallidum                    90.9569    6.9118   39.0000  109.0000   70.0000
 9 14     1863     663.4 3rd-Ventricle                    38.3065   13.2033   11.0000   73.0000   62.0000
 10 15     4110    1458.1 4th-Ventricle                    31.4457   11.5906   11.0000   73.0000   62.0000
 11 16    57498   19626.8 Brain-Stem                       80.1195    8.8419   17.0000  111.0000   94.0000
 12 17    11009    3687.8 Left-Hippocampus                 64.4524    7.7197   21.0000   96.0000   75.0000
 13 18     3836    1299.8 Left-Amygdala                    62.8180    6.4462   33.0000   83.0000   50.0000
 14 24     2872     958.5 CSF                              44.5933   13.6240   15.0000   97.0000   82.0000
 15 26     1621     547.5 Left-Accumbens-area              70.0956    6.6855   21.0000   87.0000   66.0000
 16 28    12429    4141.1 Left-VentralDC                   85.4310   10.3448   19.0000  108.0000   89.0000
 17 30       49      25.9 Left-vessel                      56.8163    7.2935   32.0000   69.0000   37.0000
 18 31     1120     372.4 Left-choroid-plexus              53.3348   11.7100   18.0000   86.0000   68.0000
 19 43    14869    5206.5 Right-Lateral-Ventricle          33.5337   14.0357    7.0000   91.0000   84.0000
 20 44      657     266.5 Right-Inf-Lat-Vent               45.2953   12.1767   17.0000   88.0000   71.0000
 21 46    56785   19552.6 Right-Cerebellum-White-Matter    77.5366    9.1843   19.0000  100.0000   81.0000
 22 47   163433   56188.2 Right-Cerebellum-Cortex          63.3668    8.8083   16.0000   95.0000   79.0000
 23 49    20893    6985.6 Right-Thalamus-Proper            86.0407   10.3032   27.0000  111.0000   84.0000
 24 50    11145    3814.2 Right-Caudate                    74.8492    7.5833   45.0000  103.0000   58.0000
 25 51    14128    4888.6 Right-Putamen                    80.7402    6.5321   44.0000  104.0000   60.0000
 26 52     5341    1736.3 Right-Pallidum                   93.4239    6.1032   46.0000  109.0000   63.0000
 27 53    11399    3861.1 Right-Hippocampus                65.9275    7.3061   34.0000  102.0000   68.0000
 28 54     4239    1412.2 Right-Amygdala                   63.2640    6.9283   30.0000  102.0000   72.0000
 29 58     1510     510.4 Right-Accumbens-area             71.0742    5.3612   48.0000   93.0000   45.0000
 30 60    11723    3884.1 Right-VentralDC                  86.7650   10.9309   23.0000  111.0000   88.0000
 31 62       33      17.0 Right-vessel                     56.2727    8.0478   39.0000   73.0000   34.0000
 32 63     1310     439.3 Right-choroid-plexus             53.4656   12.4803   23.0000   85.0000   62.0000
 33 72        0       0.0 5th-Ventricle                     0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000
 34 77     2290     713.0 WM-hypointensities               71.8258   11.6413   36.0000  105.0000   69.0000
 35 78        0       0.0 Left-WM-hypointensities           0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000
 36 79        0       0.0 Right-WM-hypointensities          0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000
 37 80        0       0.0 non-WM-hypointensities            0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000
 38 81        0       0.0 Left-non-WM-hypointensities       0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000
 39 82        0       0.0 Right-non-WM-hypointensities      0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000    0.0000
 40 85      576     208.2 Optic-Chiasm                     73.1979   15.5846   28.0000  100.0000   72.0000
 41 251     2189     711.4 CC_Posterior                    103.1558   13.1432   40.0000  120.0000   80.0000
 42 252     1288     409.4 CC_Mid_Posterior                 97.6079   16.6021   26.0000  120.0000   94.0000
 43 253     1703     556.6 CC_Central                       89.3676   13.4535   38.0000  111.0000   73.0000
 44 254     1529     492.8 CC_Mid_Anterior                  94.3931   14.5866   28.0000  119.0000   91.0000
 45 255     2421     802.6 CC_Anterior                      98.2759   13.0648   29.0000  118.0000   89.0000
It is in all my processed subjects. Could you please comment on?
Thank you in advance,
Antonin Skoch