Hi All,
We have recently uncovered problems with version 5.2. Based on these
problems, we are recommending that people stop using 5.2, mainly in
regards to usage of the surface data. A new version, 5.3, will be
released within two weeks, and a beta version for each platform will be
available within a couple days.
There were two main problems that were uncovered. First, a change was made
that was only meant to affect the white surface placement in
high-resolution data sets, but unfortunately is being applied to all data
sets. This causes the white surface to contract a small amount. This causes
the surface area to be smaller and cortex to be measured as thicker
relative to version 5.1. Visually, the surfaces do not necessarily look
less accurate, but we feel that the systematic differences with previous
versions are ill-advised without a clear reason for the change.
Second, a change made to the placement of the pial surface in order to
improve the positioning based on T2/FLAIR that caused it to extend too far
in some data sets during the T1-based pial surface deformation. This
unfortunately became the default behavior, which was not intended. None of
the dozens of test data sets we ran displayed this problem. The behavior
was reported by other users which led us to the bug.
In general, we rigorously test each version. However, our systematic
comparison of a new version with previous versions which would have caught
these problems was conducted prior to these changes. We are now tightening
and regimenting our testing procedures to ensure this doesnt happen again.
Note that there are no problems with the volumetric segmentation (aseg)
in version 5.2.
We realize that this will cause a substantial inconvenience for users. We
have isolated and fixed the problems and have run two rounds of alpha
testing and have one more to go, after which we will release a beta version
in a couple of days to anyone that wants it.
sorry for the problems.
Bruce