Hello,
Is there any paper talking about the variability of the used methods (on reconall )? Especially the parcellation? If I reprocess one subject 10 times with the same Freesurfer version, should I expect the same result for parcellation?
The freesurfer version that I use is stable3
I tried to see if the parcellation of the new Freesurfer version is similar (visually) to the stable3, and it was very different, is the parcellation method the same in both version?
thanks
Hi Leila,
Xiao Han's NeuroImage paper discusses thickness variability, and we've looked at parcellation variability in-house, but I don't think we've published on it. The V4 parcellation is should be a bit more accurate at the midline, but not substantially different.
cheers, Bruce On Wed, 5 Sep 2007, Leila BH wrote:
Hello,
Is there any paper talking about the variability of the used methods (on reconall )? Especially the parcellation? If I reprocess one subject 10 times with the same Freesurfer version, should I expect the same result for parcellation?
The freesurfer version that I use is stable3
I tried to see if the parcellation of the new Freesurfer version is similar (visually) to the stable3, and it was very different, is the parcellation method the same in both version?
thanks
Hi Leila,
I just wanted to let you know that I took a look at the parcellation snap shots you sent along (the rostro-lateral views of the frontal cortex) using V3 and V4 and it seems from these that at least for the superior, and middle frontal gyri, the V4 image is indeed more accurate (i.e. follows the contours of sulcal boundaries) than the V3 image. There indeed is some variablity between the V4 and V3 versions as the V4 version should be more anatomically accurate than the prior version.
Hope this is of help,
rahul
Hello,
Is there any paper talking about the variability of the used methods (on reconall )? Especially the parcellation? If I reprocess one subject 10 times with the same Freesurfer version, should I expect the same result for parcellation?
The freesurfer version that I use is stable3
I tried to see if the parcellation of the new Freesurfer version is similar (visually) to the stable3, and it was very different, is the parcellation method the same in both version?
thanks
Freesurfer mailing list Freesurfer@nmr.mgh.harvard.edu https://mail.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/mailman/listinfo/freesurfer
freesurfer@nmr.mgh.harvard.edu