Hello to the kind folks at FreeSurfer. I'm resending this e-mail as
I'm thinking it may not have come through..
We have some remaining questions surround average subjects and group
analysis:
1) In visualizing the surface of an average subject (such as
when running
QDEC analyses) the brain surface seems to be "incompletely
inflated"
compared to viewing a single subjects inflated hemisphere in
tksurfer (major
sulci still show depressions on the average subjects surface).
What is the
reason/explanation for this?
2) The main discussion I have seen on the validity of using an
average
subject vs a custom one (M. Harms and Mr. Fischl) have centered
around
registration. If I understand correctly, registration will align
various
surfaces (and thereby influence which voxels fall into a particular
ROI/label), but will not substantively change the thickness
values of the
surfaces in question. Is this correct? If this is so, it would
appear that
the primary issue with using the buckner40 average subject would
be the
mapping of vertices into various regions, but that this would
NOT interfere
with generating accurate statistical maps of thickness measures
for ones own
data set.
I can see that imperfect alignment of vertices across a group
may introduce
errors in the averages for a given point. It seems
make_average_subject
essentially does precisely this, so accurate registration for a
particular
population would maximize the accuracy of any given vertices
average. Is
this what making a custom subject atlas seeks to do: the make the
registration between subjects in an average as "linear" as
possible to
maximize the accuracy of each averaged vertex?
If anyone could answer this issue for me/point me towards a more
complete
resource I would very much appreciate it.
3) There has been an exchange between Graham Wideman, Mr. Fischl
and Mr,
Greve about creating one's own average subject. Mr. Greve
metioned adding
"hooks" into make_average_subject in order to make the
generation of a
custom atlas more accessible (and then using -surfreg-to-subject
in the
recon-all stream). Is there any documentation/further
explanation of what
these hooks are and how to go about completing this process
(can't find
anything on the wiki)?
Many thanks in advance!
-Mischka