Dear Bruce, Doug, Nick, and other co-workers,
As authors of the recent paper “The effects of FreeSurfer version,
workstation type, and Macintosh operating system version on
anatomical volume and cortical thickness measurements” we would like
to take the opportunity to respond to the numerous e-mails and
reactions written on mailings lists and websites. We have never
expected that our paper would have such an adverse impact. We have
noticed that several so-called “journalists” have misinterpreted and
erroneously extrapolated our conclusions. Even though this is not in
our hands, we want to express our disappointment of these events and
that we feel very uncomfortable with the created harassment.
We want to stress that it has never been our intention to put
FreeSurfer in a bad light or to blame its developers, rather we
wanted to quantify the effects that you frequently warned the users
about. The results of our study confirm your recommendations and
increase the awareness of such effects to (novice) users.
It is of course unavoidable that modifications to algorithms will
produce different results; we, nevertheless, must admit that we were
surprised that some effects were rather large.
We are using FreeSurfer frequently for our MRI data and we definitely
intend to do so in the future. We are impressed by the efforts of
your team to improve the algorithms and to extend the capabilities of
FreeSurfer. We are most grateful to you and the other developers
because these continuing efforts enabled and will enable us to
perform our research in a valid and proper manner.
Unfortunately, the media attention gave the impression that our
conclusions would only be directed to FreeSurfer. We have written in
our discussion section that some of the conclusions may apply to
other packages in the field of neuroimaging as well. We hope that you
can acknowledge our sincere intention to examine and increase
awareness of uncontrolled variation in MRI data analyses in general
and not to pinpoint Freesurfer. Therefore, we have informed also the
users and developers of FSL about possible similar effects.
Ed Gronenschild,
Petra Habets,
Heidi Jacobs,
Ron Mengelers,
Nico Rozendaal,
Jim van Os,
Machteld Marcelis