Freesurfer

freesurfer@nmr.mgh.harvard.edu

22 participants
30074 discussions

[FreeSurfer] Different results for T1 vs T2 preprocessing (recon-all 7.4.1, Ubuntu 22.04)
by 이준혁 25 Aug '25

25 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution Hello FreeSurfer team, I am preprocessing the IXI dataset and noticed that my T2 results look incorrect, even when I run the same pipeline as for T1 with only the input changed to the T2 file. I would appreciate guidance on what I’m doing wrong or how I should process T2 properly. Environment - OS: Ubuntu 22.04.5 LTS - FreeSurfer: 7.4.1 - SUBJECTS_DIR: /mnt/e/freesurfer_subjects - FSF_OUTPUT_FORMAT: nii.gz (default unless noted) What I ran - For a single subject, I tried: input="/mnt/e/T2_all/12subject_12.nii.gz" sid="subject_12T2" outdir="/mnt/e/output" 1) recon-all stage 1 recon-all -parallel -i "$input" -autorecon1 -subjid "$sid" 2) Apply Talairach transform mri_convert "$SUBJECTS_DIR/$sid/mri/brainmask.mgz" --apply_transform "$SUBJECTS_DIR/$sid/mri/transforms/talairach.xfm" -o "$SUBJECTS_DIR/$sid/mri/brainmask_align.mgz" 3) Convert to NIfTI mri_convert "$SUBJECTS_DIR/$sid/mri/brainmask_align.mgz" "$outdir/${sid}_brainmask_align.nii.gz" Issue - The T2 result looks abnormal (while T1 looks OK). I assumed I could reuse the exact same steps for T2, just swapping the input file. - Additionally, when I follow the steps from this guide: https://secure-web.cisco.com/1E1tkmifDB72D9Pbo3i9gNVonTconZI613a_nQKLd5pOD7… my output NIfTI “info” (dimensions, sform/qform, etc.) is slightly different from the author’s preprocessed files (e.g., they have 160×192 while mine often become 256×256×256 after conformation). I’d like to understand why. Questions 1) Is it correct that FreeSurfer’s recon-all is primarily designed for T1, and that T2 should NOT be run through the same standalone pipeline? 2)Then, how can I preprocess T2 using the same code as T1? Is there another method within FreeSurfer to handle T2 properly? 3) “Could you explain why some of the ‘info’ fields differ between the author’s preprocessed files and my outputs, even though I followed the same code?” Thank you very much for your time and guidance! Best regards, [JHL]

1 0

Results of Freesurfer 8.1.0 & Synthseg sometimes deviate by a factor of 1000
by Steinbacher Jürgen 22 Aug '25

22 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution Hello, I had the problem already with FS 7.2.0, but since it also occurs in FS 8.1.0, which I currently have installed on UBUNTU 20.24, an answer would be helpful. I am fully aware that FS and Synthseg do not provide exactly the same results when calculating the volumes for the same T1 scan with FS and Synthseg. E.g when I calculate a T1 3D 1mm ISO scan and a FLAIR 3D 2mm ISO scan of the same person both with Synthseg, I also fully understand that the results will not be exactly the same here either. However, what I do not understand is that the results for sub-volumes sometimes deviate by a factor of 1000? I have attached a small table below: row 1 Synthseg T1 scan, row 2 Synthseg FLAIR scan, row 3 FS T1 scan same subject. E.g. for "left lateral ventricle," the Synthseg FLAIR and FS results are about the same, but the Synthseg T1 does not match by a factor of 1000. For "left inferior lateral ventricle," the Synthseg FLAIR result is too large. Where do these deviations come from? Is it a unit problem??? I do not understand what is behind it. These deviations occur in all individuals in this manner. Thank you for your help, Jürgen subject total intracranial left cerebral white matter left cerebral cortex left lateral ventricle left inferior lateral ventricle left cerebellum white matter left cerebellum cortex left thalamus left caudate left putamen left pallidum 3rd ventricle 4th ventricle brain-stem left hippocampus left amygdala csf left accumbens area Syn= 02_t1_5_13 1581149.5 234530.16 279514.53 28584312 515.05 15703237 62220.02 5994828 3766241 4605884 1485176 1864659 2365228 23305277 3743831 1692543 258776.8 679.45 Syn= 02_flair_5_13 1540067.8 237580.17 278995.16 26533.9 462551 14112386 64456.68 6460912 3999.81 4585682 1717103 1535.82 1356496 26397467 3787048 1596163 211639.08 720396 fs= 02_t1.5.3 1558777.000000 212518.500000 248086.368363 30058.0 1061.2 16326.6 57684.7 5877.0 3879.4 4342.9 1751.2 2113.8 2982.3 20526.8 4015.2 1763.8 374287.9 539.0 ok ok ok ? ? ? ok ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ok ?

1 0

Re: New Install on Mac OSX Freeview crashes
by fsbuild 21 Aug '25

21 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution  Hello Markus, I don’t expect 5.3.0 to work correctly on a new silicon Mac so I would delete 5.3.0 from the new machine.  If you need to continue to do work with and/or verify results with 5.3.0, then continue to run it on your old Intel Mac. Unfortunately, the video you watched is somewhat out of date; it may not work on a silicon Mac with a newer version of MacOS to launch freeview via the Finder so you should try the command line instead (see below). The most recent info on Freesurfer updates is on,https://secure-web.cisco.com/1DjXjsw34RezA-edtO43ClMq-sDvYT3YWxP1tFdi5p6… In the section describing the 8.1.0 release, the “here” link for setup information points to,https://secure-web.cisco.com/1qWt-K1kG7BRaHmR_9Bk17_vSdjMnoSK2jE4ApMMMz2… You should setup your license file to be found in the shell environment via the FS_LICENSE environment variable as described in the 1st section SEETUP FREESURFER LICENSE The section further down the page in SETUP A MATLAB DISTRIBUTION for MACOS lists how you should set the freesurfer environment.  Please try running the bash shell as listed, and I’ve essentially listed all that below.  Once the bash shell output resembles the below, try running freeview from the command line. - R.. - - - - - - …. create a new terminal window and run the bash shell … in the output below the users home directory ($HOME) is /Users/me ... me@MyMac ~ % bash The default interactive shell is now zsh.To update your account to use zsh, please run `chsh -s /bin/zsh`.For more details, please visit https://secure-web.cisco.com/1IrAFVxZF8HFEyYf959stStn-sINjrAkNzOqg-vYOo1Gkx… me@MyMac:~$ export FREESURFER_HOME=/Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0 me@MyMac:~$ source $FREESURFER_HOME/SetUpFreeSurfer.sh-------- freesurfer-macOS-darwin_arm64-8..1.0-20250718-f30dfed --------Setting up environment for FreeSurfer/FS-FAST (and FSL)FREESURFER_HOME   /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0FSFAST_HOME       /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0/fsfastFSF_OUTPUT_FORMAT nii.gzSUBJECTS_DIR      /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0/subjectsMNI_DIR           /Applications/freesurfer/8.1..0/mni …. if you setup FS_LICENSE as listed via the instructions in the setup section of the URL listed above, you should see … me@MyMac:~$ echo $FS_LICENSE/Users/me/license.txt me@MyMac:~$ ls $FS_LICENSE/Users/me/license.txt … test running freeview ... me@MyMac:~$ which freeview/Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0/bin/freeview … make sure an empty window opens … me@MyMac:~$ freeview … if that worked, then try loading a volume … me@MyMac:~$ freeview  $FREESURFER_HOME/subjects/cvs_avg35/mri/brain.mgz You can ignore any notifications about methods/classes w.r.t window functions.

2 1

Re: RHEL / Rocky 9 support
by fsbuild 21 Aug '25

21 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution  You could try running a rocky8 OS in a singularity, docker, etc. container and then install the FS 8.1.0 rocky8 release in that.  I assume Rocky Linux supports quemu, which should allow running a VM running Rocky 8 linux.  The VM might be a more straightforward option for freeview users (which needs an X-Windows server). - R.

1 0

Re: New Install on Mac OSX Freeview crashes
by Markus Gschwind 20 Aug '25

20 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution It is me again! I meanwhile have found that I was missing the licence.txt file (it was not mentioned at that stage in the video). However, it seems that it somehow messes up the different versions 8.0.1 and 5.3.0 the shell says this now: -------- freesurfer-macOS-darwin_arm64-8.1.0-20250718-f30dfed -------- Setting up environment for FreeSurfer/FS-FAST (and FSL) WARNING: /Applications/freesurfer/fsfast does not exist FREESURFER_HOME /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0 FSFAST_HOME /Applications/freesurfer/fsfast FSF_OUTPUT_FORMAT nii.gz SUBJECTS_DIR /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0/subjects MNI_DIR /Applications/freesurfer/mni WARNING: MINC_BIN_DIR '/Applications/freesurfer/mni/bin' does not exist. WARNING: MINC_LIB_DIR '/Applications/freesurfer/mni/lib' does not exist. FSL_DIR /Applications/fsl Therefore I am not sure how to disentangle the versions. Should I just delete the whole 5.3.0? FREESURFER_HOME is set to /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0 however, why does it not finde the right FSFAST_HOME etc.? Thank you in advance! Markus On Wed, Aug 20, 2025 at 10:03 PM Markus Gschwind <markus.gschwind(a)gmail.com> wrote: > Dear experts, > > After 10 long years, I needed to reinstall FS on a new Mac (M3, running > Sonoma 14.6.1) > > I followed the nice video > https://secure-web.cisco.com/1pQUoPxp0Jn8y34GG4ZV-O7mpRrazzS59AXLr4MQCUn_fy… > (thank you!) > > and I downloaded the freesurfer-macOS-darwin_arm64-8.1.0.pkg > > However, when I try to load a volume into Freeview, it crashes. > > When starting Freeview from a Terminal, it crashes too, saying > > /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0/bin/freeview: line 2: 87707 Segmentation > fault: 11 $FREESURFER_HOME/Freeview.app/Contents/MacOS/freeview "$@" > > > Could anyone please guide me to correct the problem? > Thank you in advance! > Best regards > Markus >

1 0

New Install on Mac OSX Freeview crashes
by Markus Gschwind 20 Aug '25

20 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution Dear experts, After 10 long years, I needed to reinstall FS on a new Mac (M3, running Sonoma 14.6.1) I followed the nice video https://secure-web.cisco.com/1vGHacmgs-MdkkWjxuHZMMNq48_myOg-DOSd3X_WyADx2h… (thank you!) and I downloaded the freesurfer-macOS-darwin_arm64-8.1.0.pkg However, when I try to load a volume into Freeview, it crashes. When starting Freeview from a Terminal, it crashes too, saying /Applications/freesurfer/8.1.0/bin/freeview: line 2: 87707 Segmentation > fault: 11 $FREESURFER_HOME/Freeview.app/Contents/MacOS/freeview "$@" Could anyone please guide me to correct the problem? Thank you in advance! Best regards Markus

1 0

Re: RHEL / Rocky 9 support
by fsbuild 20 Aug '25

20 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution  The freesurfer development build on Rocky 9 Linux still has some run time bugs and is not entirely tested, so it is not currently fit for real work or public preview/release.  At some point in the near future I anticipate we could send out a notice to the list and ask people to try out the Rocky9 binaries and provide feedback (but not switch from doing work with a current stable freesurfer release like the current 8.1.0 release). - R..

2 1

Freesurfer 8.1.0 failed with hires opton
by Su, Weizhong 18 Aug '25

18 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution Hello FreeSurfer Developers, I'm attempting to use Freesurfer v8.1.0 with -hires option (mris_inflate -n 50), but I get the following error when I run the recon-all command: mris_inflate -no-save-sulc 50 ../surf/lh.smoothwm.nofix ../surf/lh.inflated.nofix Not saving sulc Reading 50 ** failed to open GIFTI XML file '50.gii' mrisReadGIFTIdanum: ERROR reading gifti 50.gii [INFO] read, cannot find 50, trying 50.gii ... error: No such file or directory error: mris_inflate: could not read surface file 50\00 Command exited with non-zero status 255 I have tired recon-all without -hires option, and FS finished without any error. Does anyone have any thoughts on how to trouble-shoot this one? 1) FreeSurfer version: freesurfer_ubuntu22-8.1.0_amd64.deb 2) Platform: Ubuntu V22.0.4 3) uname -a: Linux hpc11 5.15.0-105-generic #115-Ubuntu SMP Mon Apr 15 09:52:04 UTC 2024 x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux 4) recon-all.log: see attached Another question regarding Freesurfer v8: Is it still good to use T2 for pial surface refinement since FS v8 has used machine learning approach already? Thanks, Wayne

2 2

RHEL / Rocky 9 support
by Mark Janse 18 Aug '25

18 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution Hi all, Like many institutions, we are migrating our HPC facilities and related workstations from Red Hat Enterprise Linux 7 to 9. I see the most recent RHEL-derived OS you provide builds for is Rocky 8. Are there any plans to make builds for Rocky or RHEL 9 available? RHEL 10 just got released a couple months ago and RHEL 9 is already a couple years old at this point, so it's not super bleeding edge or anything. Kind regards, Mark Janse, M.Sc. Computational Scientist - BioHPC UT Southwestern Medical Center Email: markus.janse(a)utsouthwestern.edu<mailto:markus.janse@utsouthwestern.edu> ________________________________ UT Southwestern Medical Center The future of medicine, today.

1 0

(no subject)
by 田质文 15 Aug '25

15 Aug '25

External Email - Use Caution I need to get the license.txt,please. 广东省智能科学与技术研究院田质文实习生

1 0

Jump to page:

2026

2025

2024

2023

2022

2021

2020

2019

2018

2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

Freesurfer