Hi all,
I have seen others post a similar problem on the freesurfer mailing list but I could not find a solution.
When I edit a volume using control points, I am noticing that the use of CP edits adversely effects the wm/gm surfaces in the resulting re-processed image. Like others have reported, the surfaces are adversely affected in locations distant from the CP edits. The temporal lobes are particularly affected.
We are using freesurfer 5.1. I have noticed the following things:
1. The problem occurs irrespective of the number of control points added, i.e. whether >100 or <10 control points added 2. The problem occurred when only one CP was added in a voxel that was clearly wm 3. The problem did not occur after reprocessing with FS 4.5 4. I have tried the flag to disable mri_ca_normalize when reprocessing with –autorecon2. This did not seem to help. I used the command: recon-all –nocanorm –autorecon2-cp –subjid $SUBJ
I have screenshots available that illustrate the changes in the surfaces after reprocessing.
Could anyone help with this problem?
Thank-you,
Vanessa
Hi Vanessa
if you can upload an example (the entire subject dir) before adding the single control point you refer to, and after adding it we'll track it down.
thanks Bruce
On Thu, 11 Oct 2012, Vanessa Louise Cropley wrote:
Hi all,
I have seen others post a similar problem on the freesurfer mailing list but I could not find a solution.
When I edit a volume using control points, I am noticing that the use of CP edits adversely effects the wm/gm surfaces in the resulting re-processed image. Like others have reported, the surfaces are adversely affected in locations distant from the CP edits. The temporal lobes are particularly affected.
We are using freesurfer 5.1. I have noticed the following things:
- The problem occurs irrespective of the number of control points added, i.e. whether >100 or <10 control points added
- The problem occurred when only one CP was added in a voxel that was clearly wm
- The problem did not occur after reprocessing with FS 4.5
- I have tried the flag to disable mri_ca_normalize when reprocessing with ?autorecon2. This did not seem to help. I used the command: recon-all ?nocanorm ?autorecon2-cp ?subjid $SUBJ
I have screenshots available that illustrate the changes in the surfaces after reprocessing.
Could anyone help with this problem?
Thank-you,
Vanessa
freesurfer@nmr.mgh.harvard.edu